Elections Have Consequences

This November election was a shellacking for Republicans at all levels of government. There is no sugarcoating the magnitude of the losses we suffered across the nation. The House and Senate are now solidly in Democratic hands, making President Trump’s final two years in office difficult. In states like Texas, the incoming governor has already unveiled an ambitious progressive agenda. Elections have consequences.

Here in Illinois, the results were as bad as usual, only worse. The Illinois House is down to just 33 Republicans (to the Democrats’ 85) and the Senate to 14 (to the Democrats’ 45). Statewide, our gubernatorial ticket of Darren Bailey and Aaron Del Mar was outspent roughly 30-to-1 and stands at about 36 percent of the vote.

Election Day has not been a particularly fun time for an Illinois Republican these past 25 years. The long-term causes are familiar: corruption that reached our own Governor’s office, six party chairs in 13 years, the departure of our largest donors, and a habit of fighting each other harder than we fight Democrats.

Too often, we have also failed to give suburban voters a candidate or a message they could say yes to. That one is on us.

Why we lost seats this year

Some of it was beyond our control. It was a midterm with a Republican in the White House, and the national mood drove Democrats to the polls. We ran under legislative maps so contorted that the Princeton Gerrymandering Project gave the House map an F for compactness. I was a plaintiff in the lawsuit House Republicans brought against it in 2025. The governor who signed those maps had promised to veto partisan gerrymandering. Remember that the next time someone tells you JB Pritzker keeps his word. We are losing residents to other states, and I believe more of them are ours than theirs.

Some of it was within our control. Democrats have made permanent vote-by-mail their own, which gives them an enormous head start in a midterm. Nothing stops us from making better use of it, and we haven’t. And Democrats spent considerably more on competitive races, with enough left over to make safe Republican seats competitive.

The Del Mar proposal

This week Aaron Del Mar called for a radical reorganization of the Illinois GOP, with a convention in March 2027 to adopt new bylaws, structure, and platform. Aaron is right that what we are doing is not working. I do not think his plan fixes it.

First, the state party’s leadership is largely new. The State Central Committee is the party’s governing board, with one member from each of our 17 congressional districts. Only three are holdovers, Aaron among them. The rest took their seats in April, and Chairman Bob Grogan was elected in May. They inherited this cycle. Let them build one.

Second, Aaron wants Republican primary voters to elect State Central Committee members directly, as Democrats do. I understand the appeal: accountability. But those members are already chosen by committeemen like me, and we answer to primary voters every four years. Direct campaigns can be expensive (several Democratic races have run well into six figures), they get little attention at the bottom of a crowded ballot, and Democrats have meddled in our primaries before. I don’t see more accountability at the end of that road, just more cost and more risk.

Third, a March 2027 convention would come a year before the one we are already required to hold in 2028. We risk spending the spring fighting over party offices instead of recruiting candidates and raising money.

Fourth, the messenger has some accounting to do. Aaron’s press conference came less than a week after a monumental loss on a ticket bearing his name. That ticket raised little money. Governor Pritzker felt free to spend his fall investing in races in Michigan, Texas, and Ohio. Aaron’s place on the ticket was supposed to boost our vote in suburban Chicago. It did not. Not one legislative candidate I spoke with received help from the campaign.

In August, Aaron demanded the state party give the campaign $150,000. When that motion failed, Tom DeVore published more than 100 social media posts attacking the state party, Chairman Grogan, Leaders Curran and McCombie, Ted Dabrowski, and others, at one point calling Dabrowski and “his people” evil. Aaron could have said DeVore did not speak for the campaign. Instead he sat down with him for a three-hour podcast airing the same grievances.

On Monday I heard no introspection, only a plan to restructure everyone else. Aaron has talent and energy, and this party needs both. But reform starts with owning your share, and he has not yet done that.

Accountability runs in every direction

If I am going to ask Aaron to own his share, I should be consistent. New leaders deserve time. Leaders with a record should be judged on it. John Curran and Tony McCombie have led our Senate and House caucuses since the 2022 election, and the House and Senate Republican organizations answer to them. We have gone from 19 senators to 14 and from 40 representatives to 33.

The map and the national mood were not their doing. Their organizations’ spending, strategy, and coordination were their responsibility. In my judgment, they fell short on all three.

Help for Seth Lewis came too late, and Martin McLaughlin had to wonder whether help was coming at all. Our side leaned on mailers while Democrats were on television, where one message can lift several candidates at once. And too often the House and Senate organizations worked around the state party and around local organizations like ours instead of with us.

Too many candidates received little support, including help that did not require a large campaign expenditure. I saw it here. Dan Behr and Kate McGrath worked as hard as any candidates I have recruited, and they did it largely alone.

I respect both leaders, and I did not appreciate the personal attacks on them this fall. But this is a results business, and I believe both caucuses need new leadership.

The same goes for Washington. Senate Republicans lost their majority and then kept John Thune as leader without a contest. I think that was a mistake.

What we do now

Let me be clear about the standard I am applying, because I have just spent a good many paragraphs criticizing fellow Republicans. Disagreement over strategy and leadership is legitimate, and we need more of it in the open. Personal vilification is not, and neither is working to defeat our own nominees. We saw both this cycle, in a Cook County Board race and one in DuPage, and before that in the 10th District in 2024. Each one cost us.

Whoever leads the House and Senate organizations next, they have to work with the state party and with county and township organizations instead of around us. We know our precincts and our candidates. Use us.

We also have to raise more money at ALL levels, and that includes us. We will not match JB’s inherited wealth, but we have to be able to run competitive races. Each level has its job. The House and Senate Republican organizations exist to fund and support our legislative candidates. A township organization like ours raises money to reach voters, through sample ballots, mailings, and getting out the vote, and to support candidates in a small way. The candidates themselves have to raise the rest. When I recruit them, I tell them the truth: their opponent has $300,000 in the bank, and they will largely have to raise money on their own. We were fortunate to have hard-working legislative candidates in Dan Behr, Kate McGrath, Joe Johnson, and Jim Geldermann. But we had no candidate in the 58th District, and across the area Republicans did not field credible congressional campaigns.

In Northfield, I was dismayed at our turnout. We did not reach the low-propensity Republican voters we set out to reach. I was not dismayed by our volunteers, who walked precincts, made calls, wrote postcards, and did everything asked of them. Thank you to all of you who helped.

So here is what I am committing to:

  1. A hard review of our turnout and tactics, precinct by precinct, with the results shared with you.
  2. Earlier recruiting. We start now on the legislative districts and on working with neighboring organizations to find congressional candidates who will actually run.
  3. A stronger fundraising base for our organization, so we can reach more voters and do our part for the ticket.
  4. Vote-by-mail. We will offer every identified Republican voter in Northfield Township help enrolling in permanent vote-by-mail, if that is how they wish to vote.

On that last point, I will be straight with you about the tradeoffs: you have to keep your address current, and if you want a different party’s primary ballot you have to change your selection with the Clerk ahead of time. We will help with both. The choice is yours.

If you can walk a precinct, write a check, or know someone who ought to run, I want to hear from you. Email me at [email protected].

There is a lot of noise in the Illinois Republican Party right now, and a few serious problems. Let’s keep our eyes on the serious ones. Do not worry about the mouse pellets when the elephants are stampeding!

T.J. Brown

About

Northfield Township Committeeman. Involved in Republican politics for nearly 30 years, from assisting local organizations and campaigns to campaign management and field work.